Who’s in charge? Who will be in charge? - 11.19.26

John Zogby: [00:00:00] who's minding the store and who's addressing the nation and who is allaying fears? I am really troubled by this,

Jeremy Zogby: we are in the middle of a crisis, full spectrum crisis. but I don't wanna lose the fact that after we get through that crisis, which we will, as we always have, that will be the opportunity for a renewal.

John Zogby: Vance part is easy to understand. There are two distinct elements within, still within the Republican Party, and I think he's managed to alienate both.

Jeremy Zogby: There is competition and that the Democratic Party is open to the notion of different profiles leading their party. think that's important

John Zogby: It's Thursday, November 19th, my brother's birthday, and [00:01:00] this is a, a special edition, 'cause it's not Friday, special edition of The Zogby Report, Real Polling in Real Time. And we're gonna talk about some real polling. there is a message already for both the Democratic Party and the Republican Party about who has pulled into the leads in, both parties.

it's very early, but we're getting some signals from, likely primary voters, two years into the future. So why don't I talk about that in the second part of this brief podcast? The first thing I wanna talk about is At least a dozen major, quotation marks, coincidences involving, s- some of the largest, most iconic corporations, the, [00:02:00] large and homeland security-focused National Security Administration, the Federal Aviation Administration, United Airlines, and more into the hotel industry, Marriott, all breaking down over a period of 72 hours, maybe even into a fourth day.

But coincidences of this magnitude all for the same alleged reasons, of a breakdown of old wiring or a changeover from an old system, analog to digital, all spokespeople reading from the same script and not generating much trust or credibility among the American [00:03:00] people. And I'll end this by saying, who's in charge?

There are people who are-- Stores are reporting being sold out of backup generators. This is like everybody's car not starting at the same time what is going on here? And that old saw of a script that we have a changeover or there's been a breakdown of, old communications infrastructure all happening at the same time to Microsoft, to Apple, for God's sakes, to Marriott, United Airlines.

Meanwhile, the president's clinking glasses. We'll find out what the outcome of his talks with President Xi and President Putin are going to be, maybe much ado about nothing. [00:04:00] But who's minding the store and who's addressing the nation and who is allaying fears? I am really troubled by this, and I have to say, I grew up in a different generation.

I grew up, where there's an element of trust, a, a sense that there are some good guys out there. I don't feel like that right now. And, yeah, I... What do you think?

Jeremy Zogby: Wow. What a way to start. there, look, there are many different interpretations

One interpretation in line what I've been writing about recently is, the, the shelf life of a regime,

that regime [00:05:00] is the post-war American world order. And a sh- a regime has a shelf life of about eighty years. began in nineteen forty-five. This is two thousand twenty-six. That's eighty-one years. we're looking at the... We're in the threshold of the end of that order.

And w- when you go through that process, you look at previous examples previous regimes that ended, gets ugly on multiple fronts, not just militarily, not just monetarily, but also in terms of infrastructure. Could there be some truth in the n- the notion that some of these, agencies that are decades old, have crumbling infrastructure? It could be true, but you raise a good question about the [00:06:00] coincidence when you throw into the mix the premier, um, technological firms are moving us into the future or at least attempting to. another interpretation is that, governments have been warning us about this, right? This stuff has been ramping up, governments. Thirty-three governments around the world telling their citizens to prepare. coming. have three days, says one government. Has-- have a week of supply, says another.

Have thirty, South Korea. And this has been, the chatter since about September. Meanwhile, talks about cyber attacks are increasing.

is a cynical interpretation governments knew about this and know about this, and I don't know. regardless, it looks like the public is taking cue, [00:07:00] and they're bracing for impact.

John Zogby: Yeah

Jeremy Zogby: we are in the middle of a crisis, full spectrum crisis. but I don't wanna lose the fact that after we get through that crisis, which we will, as we always have, that will be the opportunity for a renewal. Whatever comes after it in terms of whatever the world order is, we'll get through it. w- it's very difficult when you're in the midst of it,

but don't lose sight of that. That's about all I have to say

John Zogby: Yeah. And I'm just gonna close my end of this, by saying I'm a great believer. We're, we are in the middle of a, of a re- of a revolution that's happening, very quickly, and we will end up [00:08:00] on the right side of things. It'll, it will right itself. No, we'll, we will actually right it, and I think we've begun that process already.

But here's the thing.

Think of your utility company, your cable service provider. You get a note saying, "We, we will doing, be doing repairs. We will be upgrading our systems. You may experience a shutdown between such and such hours." That's what you do, right?

If these were coincidental or, these were planned changeovers, then there are so many Apple customers, so many Microsoft customers, so many United customers, they would not have been [00:09:00] alerted beforehand, especially people who are in the middle of catching flights or, y- utilizing those services on a, regular basis.

This is what stretches, credibility right here. Go ahead. I'm sorry.

Jeremy Zogby: I'm just combining the two things we're saying. You're saying revolution, I'm saying, an order in decay. I think what happens first is the order decays,

then the revolution is the response. So it's not one or the other. it's, both, and that's all I wanted to add. But you wanted to talk about 2028,

John Zogby: I do, very much.

Jeremy Zogby: what we're experts on,

John Zogby: Yes. yeah, the- we're just thinking aloud as citizens right now. yeah, I think there's some messages already. [00:10:00] It is way too early. Name recognition is still a factor. But let's look at the Republicans first This is some new polling by our colleagues at, at Emerson.

And essentially, all throughout, the, the year, we've seen, J.D. Vance, the vice president, in the lead, and followed closely in some instances, not so closely in other instances, by Secretary of State Marco Rubio. But in today's polling from Emerson, we see Rubio actually 20 points ahead, 44 to 24 over Vance.

that means, for starters, about a 15, 18-point drop for Vance and about the [00:11:00] same, in terms of an increase for Rubio. the Vance part is easy to understand. There are two distinct elements within, still within the Republican Party, and I think he's managed to alienate both. For starters, by coming out right after the election and blaming the war in Iran while he is part of the administration, part of the, Trump-Vance team that brought to us the, the, war in Iran.

And at the same time, he has generated a, an enormous amount of distrust among those non-MAGA Republicans about trying to pin down and define exactly who he is and what his core values are. Meanwhile, Rubio is widely rumored to be leaving the administration. this could be a natural time for him to [00:12:00] do that.

The president's job performance ratings in the last five polls average at 37, and, this could be a good time for Rubio to kinda declare his, independence and maintain a level of independence, in order for him to run for, president. Gone, from the mix is Ron DeSantis polling at 9 or 10%, and then, no other names really, are very credible.

Let's talk about that and before we move on to the Dems

Jeremy Zogby: Yeah. So I'm just looking through a string of polls, on the Democratic side, it's, it's, much more clear, at least if you look at the most recent 2028 polls. You go back three or four, and what you see consistently across, whether it's Atlas, [00:13:00] whether it is, YouGov Echelon and all the way up to Emerson in the Democratic, primary horse race, there's a four-way tie, sometimes even a five-way tie. Harris, Ossoff, Ocasio-Cortez, Buttigieg, and Newsom. I find that fascinating because that's pretty consistent across five v- very different polling organizations. And what that tells me is that there is competition and that the Democratic Party is open to the notion of different profiles leading their party. think that's important because, a year or two ago, there was still a sense within the Democratic Party of this, and I'm just gonna call it what it is, political correctness, like

a certain profile. Uh, here we [00:14:00] have Black woman, Kamala Harris, in the lead or ne- next to the lead, Jon Ossoff, a young white male, Ocasio-Cortez, a young Hispanic woman, Pete Buttigieg, uh, a young male who's gay openly, and Gavin Newsom, who's, who's been a contender.

Now, in the last polling we did, which was September, and it was this way consistently after month, was Harris somewhere around thirty, and then Newsom somewhere in the twenties, and then it would go back and forth between, and Ocasio. But what we've seen is a very interesting, explosive horse race on the Democratic side.

On the Republican side, we always had-- almost always had J.D. Vance the lead. So I'm gonna be interested in seeing what we [00:15:00] come out with, next time. what we've seen here, is, if you listen to Emerson, Rubio is way ahead of Vance. It's really just about Rubio and Vance, and Rubio's two to one. if you go to-- I'm gonna go to Rasmussen because they are quintessential Republican. they have Rubio and Vance fairly neck and neck, with DeSantis in a third place, thirteen percent. Take note of that because I, I, I, Listen, DeSantis' performance in twenty twenty-four was very disappointing. was a man who established himself as a rock star governor

state, but when he got to the stage, he did not grow into the role. honestly looked, very inexperienced and weak. I think 2028 or the road to [00:16:00] '28 is different because, for many reasons, he's held, the ground in Florida, he could emerge from 2026 and the Republican debacle, the loss, as untouched in that because, although he has MAGA talking points, he's distanced himself from that. the, the field in, as of now on the Republican side is not as competitive, but the Democratic side is looking quite explosive

John Zogby: Here's what I think we see just starting, with the, Republicans. The two things that stand out, are, of course Rubio taking off and, Vance sinking. But DeSantis actually a distant third place and someone who was really barely able to keep Florida red [00:17:00] in the 2026 elections. the-- I'm not gonna say they almost lost, the Republicans almost lost the governorship and the US Senate, but those two races were far more competitive than they have been in recent years, and Democrats actually made not only a credible showing statewide, but they seem to have, regained their, their position in the all-important South Florida, where the, the Democrats really did very well, both in terms of winning congressional seats, but also in terms of total vote in Miami-Dade and Broward Counties, the two of the largest counties, in, in the state.

Back to the Democrats. Ossoff is the one who's the flavor of the month, and one of the things he has to be very, cautious about is [00:18:00] peaking too soon. We've seen that happen a number of times. I'm struck, interestingly enough, by the five-way race, but I'm also intrigued by the fact that Andy Beshear, has gone from a dash or zero to seven points.

representing, the more moderate wing of the party, but also someone, from a red state who wins in a red state. and so he could very well be in the mix, especially as the party tries to define its identity between the, the progressives, where Ossoff is positioning himself with, AOC and, Beshear, who is positioning himself as, a, a more moderate candidate.

I did see... And here we are on November 19th. I did see [00:19:00] yesterday, an ad for Governor Newsom, clearly an image and presidential ad for Governor Newsom two years, before election day. So we're, up and running, and maybe it's not so early to be talking about any of this after all. That's all I have to say.

How about you?

Jeremy Zogby: I just have one thing on the Republican side. I- in the moment, it's difficult to imagine where does the Republican Party go from here? especially the early signals that we're getting. on the one hand, the president is saying or signaling he may be open to, some kind of negotiation Iran, nobody really can take that serious after what we've seen for several months. but then on the other hand, in the im- the immediate aftermath of that nothing short of a [00:20:00] shellacking, he appoints Stephen Miller,

hard line, the hardest of hard line MAGA. So it indicates that, there is a desire that, c- nexus of the party to hold on MAGA. But the problem is the believability factor and the real deal factor. Who will be the real deal Republican? Uh, and it-- and maybe they shift-- Maybe they don't use the terminology MAGA. Maybe they take up... and maybe they can't even use the term America first, but maybe they have to use a variation of that. My sense is the way to excite the base, the Republican base, the only way to tap into that. basically look at the farmers and the ranchers [00:21:00] that they lost in Kansas and in Texas, who in effect were, I think, the quintessential swing vote, not because of their, number, but just because those have been traditional GOP voters, and then they went away simply because of three reasons, tariffs, diesel, and labor.

but how do they get that sentiment back? How do they win the rural vote over with, with guaranteeing the rural vote in, that part of the country that whoever they're gonna front-run is the real deal? That's gonna be the major challenge for the GOP

John Zogby: I agree. And it's going to be a heavy lift, for the GOP because there's not much except sentiment that Congress can do about tariffs [00:22:00] and the price of, diesel fuel. And so that's up to the president, and I'm not so sure the president got the message. have a good week

Jeremy Zogby: Yeah. Intriguing conversation.

John Zogby: Yeah. Take care